A Gift

I was rifling through my files and I came across an unmarked envelope. I opened it of course, and was shocked to find a very old orange note book. It had travelled with me from Vichy, to Paris, to Brooklyn, to Hackensack, NJ to Amherst, MA.

When one moves one does not look at every item being transported. I know that in Brooklyn I had seen the envelope among my books. I was then a teenager. After then I guess it was just swept up with the books every time I moved and then landed in the file cabinet I acquired in Hackensack.

Sometime in 1940, or possibly 41 there was a scare that the Germans were invading Paris. Some people escaped to Vichy. My parents did and so did the parents of Rose Baum. We were both 8 years old and we met in a park. When our parents decided to leave Vichy, Rose gave me the orange note book with two poems inside. One is beautifully written in her hand, but it is not written by her. It is by Henri de Regnier. This is what is says.

“In the morning I get up and I go out of the City

The sidewalk of the street echoes the sound of my steps

And the early sun heats the old tiles

And in the narrow gardens lilac grows.

Along the wall covered in moss that the branches overtake

An echo that we follow precedes our walk,

And the sharp paving stones lead to the white road

That begins in the suburbs and leads to the fields

And here I am soon on the high side

Where we see the sun at one’s feet,

Calm, small, poor, isolated, dull,

The home town with its familiar roofs.”

At the end of the poem Rose drew a moss covered wall overhung with lilacs.

In the folder there was another poem, this one typed.

Titled “The Song of Goodbyes”. I believe it was written by Rose.

“ Must we part without hope

Without hope of returning?

Must we part without hope

Of seeing each other again one day?

It is not a goodbye, my sisters,

It is only a parting:

Yes, we will see each other again, my sisters,

It is only a parting.

Let us form with our entwined hands

At the end of the day

Let us form with our entwined hands

A chain of love.

Because God who sees us all together

And who wants to bless us

Because God who sees us all together

and who wants to bless us

Will know how to reunite us.”

Rose, an 8-year-old, who already appreciated poetry and who was already a poet herself.

Did she and her family survive World War II?

What happened to her. What sort of life did she have.

Somehow, 8-year-old me felt the need to keep her little notebook and that need has stayed with me until now

10 comments on “A Gift

  1. Dear Sue,

    Thank you so much for sending me this very moving personal history and the beautiful poems. Thinking about your childhood friend and wondering what happened to her and her family must be quite painful. It’s amazing that her orange envelope has survived so many journeys with you, and I’m so glad you unearthed it. Keep well and know that I think of you often.

  2. Doris Baran Hirsch

    November 4, 2021 at 5:20 pm Reply

    How beautiful. How touching. Oh my, I wonder what became of Rose. This is so meaningful to me. I am in the same age range. However, I was safely tucked away in The Bronx, NY. We never knew about the suffering & tragedy Jewish people during the war until many years later. I’m thinking about dear Rose Baum.
    Doris

  3. I wish you could find out what happened to her.

  4. Dear Sue
    Thanks for the moving story. It would be interesting to find out what happened to Rose. The poem is not by her it’s the lyrics of a well-known song « ce n’est qu’un au revoir » (brothers was just changed to « sisters) set to the tune of on old Scottish song « Auld Land Syne » by 18th poet Robert Burns.
    Love

    https://youtu.be/JTYsBExxxuE
    And the original version :
    https://youtu.be/sMFnqj6aFwY

  5. Dear Sue
    Thanks for the moving story. It would be interesting to find out what happened to Rose. The poem is not by her it’s the lyrics of a well-known song « ce n’est qu’un au revoir » (brothers was just changed to « sisters) set to the tune of on old Scottish song « Auld Land Syne » by 18th poet Robert Burns.
    Love

    https://youtu.be/JTYsBExxxuE
    And the original version :
    https://youtu.be/sMFnqj6aFwY

  6. This is a very sweet memory, Sue. Thanks for sharing it.

  7. I’m also curious about little Rose and whether she continued to write poetry.
    So many lives that cross paths and then diverge again after a while.
    Thank you Suzanne for this latest musing.

  8. Michael Sznajderman

    November 12, 2021 at 7:12 pm Reply

    So lovely Mom!!

  9. Michael Sznajderman

    November 12, 2021 at 7:13 pm Reply

    So lovely. Thanks for sharing Mom!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *